Overview
4.9
Pool
City:
Anna Maria
Escape to the perfect Anna Maria Island getaway in this beautifully appointed 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom ground-floor cottage, ideally located just one block from the sugar-white sands of Bean Point Beach and the tranquil waterfront of Bayfront Park.<br /><br />Designed for relaxation and connection, this charming island retreat offers everything you need for an unforgettable beach vacation.<br /><br />Private Backyard Oasis<br /><br />Step outside and discover your own tropical sanctuary. The spacious backyard features a heated private pool, a full-length patio with both sunny and shaded areas, comfortable lounge seating, and a dining space perfect for outdoor meals. Fire up the grill, soak up the Florida sunshine, or unwind poolside beneath the umbrellas after a day at the beach.<br /><br />Open Living & Dining Spaces<br /><br />Inside, the bright and welcoming open-concept layout creates the perfect gathering space for family and friends. The fully equipped kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining area, where seating for eight makes shared meals, game nights, and vacation planning easy and enjoyable.<br /><br />Sleeping Accommodations<br /><br />Primary Suite<br /><br />King bed<br />Private ensuite bathroom with dual vanities and walk-in shower<br />Direct access to outdoor living areas<br /><br />Guest Bedroom 1<br /><br />Queen bed<br /><br />Guest Bedroom 2<br /><br />Queen bed<br /><br />Bunk Room<br /><br />Twin-over-full bunk bed<br /><br />Ideal for children and additional guests<br /><br />Three well-appointed bathrooms and comfortable living spaces throughout the home ensure everyone has room to relax.<br /><br />Prime Anna Maria Island Location<br /><br />Situated in one of the island's most desirable neighborhoods, you're just moments from the pristine shoreline of Bean Point Beach, breathtaking Gulf sunsets, and peaceful bayfront parks.<br /><br />Spend your days exploring seven miles of stunning beaches, swimming in crystal-clear Gulf waters, shell hunting along the shore, or enjoying island adventures. Start your mornings with sunrise views over Tampa Bay and end your evenings watching spectacular sunsets paint the sky.<br /><br />Explore with Ease<br /><br />The free Anna Maria Island trolley operates daily from 6:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m., making it easy to visit local shops, restaurants, cafés, and attractions without ever needing to drive.<br /><br />Additional Information<br />Pool heat is recommended year-round and may be automatically included depending on the length of stay.<br />Dog-friendly property (restrictions and fees apply):<br />First dog: $150 per week<br />Additional dogs: $50 per dog, per week<br />Breed and weight restrictions apply; please inquire before booking.<br /><br />Whether you're planning a family vacation, a beach retreat with friends, or a relaxing island escape, this inviting cottage combines comfort, convenience, and the laid-back charm of Anna Maria Island for a truly memorable stay.<br /><br />Our Cancellation Policy: In order to protect our owners from loss of income, ALL MONIES PAID TOWARDS YOUR RESERVATION MAY BE NON-REFUNDABLE AFTER A CERTAIN DATE! FULL AND PARTIAL REFUNDS MAY BE GIVEN UNDER CERTAIN CONDITIONS. Ask our office for details, or check your rental agreement.
Rooms
Amenities
# of Parking Spaces
:
Yes 3
Air Conditioning
:
Yes Central
Anna Maria Island
:
Yes
BBQ Grill
:
Yes
Beach Access
:
Gulf or Bay
Beach Distance
:
Easy Walk
Bed Size 1st/Master
:
King
Bed Size 2nd Rm
:
Queen
Bed Size 3rd Rm
:
Queen
Bed Size 4th Rm
:
Full Sized Bunk Bed
Bike Rentals
:
Yes Deliveries Avail
Boat Trailer Parking
:
Yes
Ceiling Fans
:
Yes
Dep Clean and Linens
:
$448. Incl Linens
Dishwasher
:
Yes
Exercise Facility
:
Yes Nearby
Featured Property
:
Yes
Floor No.
:
Ground Floor
Floor, Ground
:
Yes
Golf
:
Yes Nearby
Heating
:
Yes Central
Internet Access
:
Yes Wi Fi
Iron/Ironing Board
:
Yes/Yes
Mandatory Pet Fee
:
$150/Week Per Pet *See Note in Desc
Microwave
:
Yes
Non-Smoking
:
Yes
Parking
:
Yes
Patio
:
Yes Poolside
Pets
:
Yes Dogs Only
Pets Allowed
:
Yes
Pool
:
Yes
Pool Heat Extra
:
Yes $150/Week
Pool, Heated
:
Yes Pool Heat Extra
Security Fee
:
$60 Non-Refundable
Square Footage, Est.
:
1400 Under Air
Tennis
:
Yes Community Courts
Tub/Shower Combo
:
Yes 2 Tub/Shower
TV Cable/Satellite
:
Yes Cable TV
TVs
:
Yes Flat Panel TVs
Walk-in Shower
:
Yes
Washer/Dryer
:
Yes/Yes
Availability
Unavailable
Prices
Location
Reviews
Analyzing what guests liked with OpenAI...
From real guest reviews summarized by OpenAI. Always check important information.
AI analysis not available at this time.
We enjoyed our stay,
Review Date: 06/12/2026
Trip Date: 05/30/2026
"Plenty of space indoor & outdoor. Outdoor showers were helpful coming back from the beach. Would highly recommend for a relaxing stay.
Reviewed By: Chris
Would definitely stay here again.
Review Date: 06/06/2026
Trip Date: 05/09/2026
"This home was clean, had everything we needed in the kitchen and the outdoor pool was perfect!
Reviewed By: Amanda S
We enjoyed our stay and everything was as described.
Review Date: 06/06/2026
Trip Date: 05/22/2026
"Would consider again for future stays at AMI.
Reviewed By: Dan G
Great place.
Review Date: 04/24/2026
Trip Date: 04/11/2026
"Pool was wonderful
Reviewed By: Lawrence F
Loved the open space in house.
Review Date: 03/12/2026
Trip Date: 02/28/2026
"Enjoyed the privacy in pool area.
Reviewed By: Lynne
The location is amazing
Review Date: 12/29/2025
Trip Date: 12/14/2025
"Check in and out was super easy. We had plenty of space for the 6 adults we had on vacation.
Reviewed By: Katie
The house was great.
Review Date: 11/12/2025
Trip Date: 10/30/2025
"We really enjoyed the location. Having the heat pool was a nice bonus. The kitchen was well equipped. It was nice and clean. There were a few things that could use an update from a renters view the master bedroom mattress (which is were we slept) could be upgraded the other bedrooms had nicer and much more comfortable mattresses. The patio furniture also should be upgraded the table and four chairs . The lounge chairs were good. Having the grill was really nice to have to cook on. I don’t want to sound critical but they were the things that we noticed. Over all it was a great place.
Reviewed By: Tracy
Huge thanks to the rental company!
Review Date: 10/25/2025
Trip Date: 10/18/2025
"Huge thanks to the rental company for taking such great care of us after being chased off by hurricane Helen in 2024! The house was clean, a great size and layout for the six of us. Lots of kitchen amenities like toaster oven, blender, coffee maker and ice maker in the freezer were much appreciated. Pool and backyard were very enjoyable. We utilized the very short two block walk to beautiful sunsets at Bean Point.
All the bed frames need help, the mattresses are comfortable but every time you roll or move at all they clunk & squeak a lot especially in the master suite.
Reviewed By: KAH
Excellent
Review Date: 09/11/2024
Trip Date: 08/30/2024
"I be back again!
Reviewed By: Gileno O
Great location
Review Date: 07/31/2024
Trip Date: 07/20/2024
"Close to Rod & Reel Pier on the North end, right where we wanted to be.
Reviewed By: William W
Girls trip
Review Date: 05/14/2024
Trip Date: 05/02/2024
"We were a block from the beach and closer than that to the pier. Our trip started years ago with just myself and my sister. Gradually we added daughters, nieces daughter-in-law, and niece-in-law. We are up to 8 most years, sometimes just 7 of us. Every year we pick the next destination. We are all so glad we chose this one this year. Several mentioned that they would do this trip again some year at the Same place. The pool was such a bonus. We could walk to the beach, walk to the pier, or just relax by the pool. We loved it! And Kate was a real pleasure to deal with. We will definitely do this again some year.
Reviewed By: Annette M
Great location to the rod & reel pier
Review Date: 03/19/2024
Trip Date: 03/09/2024
"We loved the location! Short walk to the beach & the rod & reel pier. Nice backyard & pool for hanging out. Management was very responsive to a few minor issues! Really enjoyed our stay here!
Reviewed By: Catherine B
Great AMI Location
Review Date: 12/02/2023
Trip Date: 11/18/2023
"This property is spacious and ideally located. It’s an easy walk to the beach and the Rod & Reel Pier. The backyard pool area is beautiful. There are four bedrooms so it’s a great place for families. Everything we needed was provided and we enjoyed every minute of our stay.
Reviewed By: Mary A
Great time
Review Date: 10/17/2023
Trip Date: 10/08/2023
"Very nice and private, would stay again.
Reviewed By: Ember
Great Stay
Review Date: 10/10/2023
Trip Date: 10/02/2022
"Plenty of room and had everything we needed.
Reviewed By: Cynthia C
Great and comfortable home within walking distance to the beach
Review Date: 09/15/2023
Trip Date: 08/08/2023
"Very comfortable and spacious home for a family of 8 adults. Very well-equipped kitchen! Within walking distance to the beach, which is not crowded at all due to it being in the North Point location. I would consider renting it again.
Reviewed By: Lina F
Good stay,
Review Date: 09/13/2023
Trip Date: 09/01/2023
"Nice pool
Reviewed By: Ryan M
Beautiful location, seconds from the beach.
Review Date: 08/22/2023
Trip Date: 08/16/2023
"Rod & Reel Pier provided opportunities for great food all day & dolphin watching while you eat! House is equipped with everything you need & a few initial problems were sorted immediately. Starfish Cottage is a magical place to stay & plenty big enough for our family group of six. Stunning sunsets & quality food are plentiful in this location…I would return in a heartbeat!
Reviewed By: Victoria K
Location!
Review Date: 06/13/2023
Trip Date: 06/03/2023
"Rod and Reel Pier and Bay are in the backyard and Bean Point Beach is so close you can see the beach entrance from the front yard. Pool! Beautiful, clean pool and plenty of chairs for lounging and eating. Beds! The beds are comfortable and clean. We slept well. Cleanliness! No dust and the air smelled fresh when we first arrived.
Reviewed By: Jami D
Enjoyed our stay.
Review Date: 06/02/2023
Trip Date: 05/25/2023
"The only negative was the pool was dirty and a little green. Someone came on the second day and got things cleaned up. Pool looked great after that. Great location and plenty of room. Would consider it again!
Reviewed By: Pete
AMI vacation
Review Date: 05/03/2023
Trip Date: 04/22/2023
"We love the north end and the location and size and pool were exactly what we were looking for!! Thanks for the great accommodations 👍
Reviewed By: Arthur M
Beautiful island!
Review Date: 04/26/2023
Trip Date: 04/15/2023
"The house was great! perfect location nice and quiet end of the island. Close to pine st, bean point, and Rod and Reel Pier and Beach. House had everything we needed! Can't wait to stay again!
Reviewed By: Lindsey
We had a wonderful time.
Review Date: 04/05/2023
Trip Date: 03/18/2023
"It was a well-equipped house. My only complaint was there was not an outdoor shower with warm water. However, we had a wonderful time and would rent again.
Reviewed By: Roberta
Excellent location.
Review Date: 03/21/2023
Trip Date: 03/04/2023
"Our group of five gals really enjoyed Starfish Cottage. Only one slight problem with the pool, which was very quickly attended to by both Edward G and the pool maintenance man. Once resolved, the pool was gorgeous! I hope to stay there again!
Reviewed By: Julie
Great vacation property in fantastic location
Review Date: 01/12/2023
Trip Date: 12/24/2022
"We spend our Christmas break at this property on Anna Maria Island. Great experience all around. The property was fantastic and the service from the agency was top-notch!
Reviewed By: Jerome
Loved having a lot of space
Review Date: 11/11/2022
Trip Date: 11/02/2022
""Cute house with a great location! Large groups will appreciate the 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms! Great value!“
Reviewed By: Carrie W
We were very close to the water,
Review Date: 10/25/2022
Trip Date: 10/15/2022
"From start to finish booking was extremely easy and we'll worth the money. We were very close to the water, and having our own pool was awesome. House was clean and looked well-maintained.
Reviewed By: Megan
Home away from Home!
Review Date: 10/12/2022
Trip Date: 10/01/2022
"It was not our typical visit to AMI. Traveling in on the tail of Ian had us a little concerned. We knew there was no power on the island and weren't sure of our welcome when the community was in chaos. Edward and his team were juggling to place people in other homes. The team moved us to a lovely home not far from our chosen property. We enjoyed it while we waited to move to our island home. Both houses were welcoming and well-equipped, but we felt more at home in Starfish. It is a home, not a house. We are so glad AMI avoided the storm and can't wait for our next visit. Thanks, team, for going way above and beyond for our visit. Your professionalism and kindness during this challenge were amazing.
Reviewed By: Julie
Great communication with the host made for a positive experience.
Review Date: 09/20/2022
Trip Date: 09/15/2022
"A long colleague get-a-way trip of pure relaxation. House worked well with bed, bath, and conversation areas. The pool a plus for our group of six. We were there in September (off-season) so had quick access from end to end of the island. Rented two golf carts and never needed our car. Easy in and out.
Reviewed By: Sharon
Excellent stay. Plenty of space for 6 of us!
Review Date: 08/01/2022
Trip Date: 07/09/2022
"Nice pool and private backyard. Nice amount of starter items for the kitchen, laundry, and bathroom. The beds were super cozy and the bedding was fresh and clean smelling! Perfect walking distance to Rod and Reel where we ate several times and saw dolphins and mana rays daily! Thank you to the homeowners for having us! We will be back on the island in the future for sure!
Reviewed By: Tina H
The property was exactly as listed.
Review Date: 04/07/2022
Trip Date: 03/19/2022
"It is in a fabulous location one house from the Rod’ n Reel pier. The pool is bigger than it looks in the pictures. It is an older FL home, but offered everything we needed for a great stay.
Reviewed By: Maureen
We loved the location!
Review Date: 03/18/2022
Trip Date: 03/05/2022
"It was nice! The backyard is awesome and a decent size. We definitely recommend it!
Reviewed By: Shanna
Great location!
Review Date: 11/18/2021
Trip Date: 11/07/2021
"Walk to the beach and shops, bike rentals within walking distance. A great house for a family vacation.
Reviewed By: Mary
Good place for family stays.
Review Date: 10/22/2021
Trip Date: 10/17/2021
"House with everything you need for a vacation. Anna Maria Island is a beautiful place.
Reviewed By: Cecilia
Excellent property, very roomy.
Review Date: 10/22/2021
Trip Date: 10/01/2021
"The pool was very nice but could use a railing to get in and out of for stability. Had all the conveniences. Would stay there again.
Reviewed By: Elisa
Great for us.
Review Date: 10/19/2021
Trip Date: 10/08/2021
"The house was perfect for what we were looking for!
Reviewed By: Ryann
Perfect for Us
Review Date: 08/11/2021
Trip Date: 07/24/2021
"Great location. Very responsive to any minor issue.
Reviewed By: Roger
The house and pool are amazing.
Review Date: 08/11/2021
Trip Date: 07/31/2021
"The location is awesome. Three bathrooms were a blessing with multiple teenagers. The house was the perfect size in the perfect location. The pool was amazing. The only real downside was having to keep the vacuum in the pool full time. Note to Guest) We have a pool man that is happy to remove it if we let him know. Please don't hesitate to ask for proper removal. The summer breezes and impromptu rainstorms make a daily need for vacuuming.
Reviewed By: Amanda
Would stay there again.
Review Date: 07/15/2021
Trip Date: 07/03/2021
"Great home! Just a very short walk to Rod and Reel Pier. We loved everything. Plenty of bedrooms, great kitchen, and living room area is big for everyone to gather for a movie. Pool was perfect.
Reviewed By: Tina
Great Amenities!
Review Date: 06/15/2021
Trip Date: 06/05/2021
"Wonderful week on Anna Maria Island. This house is closer to the bay, so ocean access a little far, however, we had golf carts and found shorter beach access. Pool area very lovely and functional for our group. We highly recommend Starfish cottage.
REPLY: I'm glad you found Bean Point, just one block North.
Reviewed By: Kathy
Great Amenities!
Review Date: 06/15/2021
Trip Date: 06/05/2021
"Wonderful week on Anna Maria Island. This house is closer to the bay, so ocean access a little far, however, we had golf carts and found shorter beach access. Pool area very lovely and functional for our group. We highly recommend Starfish cottage.
REPLY: I'm glad you found Bean Point, just one block North.
Reviewed By: Kathy
Would stay again!
Review Date: 05/26/2021
Trip Date: 05/15/2021
"Perfect location to watch the sunrise near Rod and Reel Pier. Sunset two knocks away. Plenty of room in the four-bedroom house. We rented a golf cart to get to the southern side of the island. Wonderful time and perfect weather!! We had an issue with the vacuum in the pool being on 24/7. Pool guy came and offered assistance. Plenty of space and great location!! All in all, I thought the house was wonderful and would stay again!!
Reviewed By: Kathy
Great place to stay.
Review Date: 05/18/2021
Trip Date: 05/08/2021
"Spacious interior, large backyard w pool, plenty of parking spaces on property and everything was super clean. Easy walk to beach or pier from the house. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking to stay on Anna Maria Island. Thanks for a great trip!
Reviewed By: Rich B
We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the Starfish Cottage.
Review Date: 04/27/2021
Trip Date: 04/17/2021
"The location was perfect for our group. We rented beach cruiser bikes so we could easily ride or walk to the beach a block and a half away. The wagon that is provided is a tremendous help with getting gear to the beach. Even closer is the Rod and Reel Pier, where we loved to grab take out seafood or watch for manatees. We loved being on the north tip of the island where is it quiet and not busy. The house worked well for our group of 8. The beds were very comfortable. Edward was very responsive with questions and a pleasure to communicate with. I would stay here again, and will recommend it to others.
Thank you for hosting us. We had a wonderful time. We absolutely loved the location of your house and enjoyed the pool area a lot.
Reviewed By: Sarah
Great Amenities and Location!
Review Date: 03/03/2021
Trip Date: 12/18/2020
"Had a blast! This home had all we needed, was spacious and the pool area was wonderful!
Reviewed By: Jeanette
BEST VACATION EVER!
Review Date: 03/03/2021
Trip Date: 02/13/2021
"We had 6 adults and two dogs that came to this property for two weeks. The location was right in the middle of it all! What a great place to be! The restaurants, the free trolley were within walking distance! And I didn’t even get to the pool area which we all rated second after the location! It is fabulous! Beautiful back yard. The cottage itself is not perfect but it is clean and large enough to support 8 large people in case it rains. There is an odd layout but that did not deter us from having a great time at all. There are many ways to works around the layout. There are 4 bedrooms and 3 baths. The master bath is a handicapped bathroom-very large. The kitchen, dining, and living areas were a decent size for entertainment. We rented a golf cart for one week and that was key in getting around the parking issues on the island. We all agreed that the worst thing about the island was the traffic getting on and off. This place was a winner for all of us. BEST VACATION EVER!
Reviewed By: Doug
Would definitely return in the future.
Review Date: 03/03/2021
Trip Date: 02/06/2021
"The house is in an absolutely perfect location for a family with kids and easy walks to beaches and restaurants. The heated pool in February was outstanding! Do not hesitate to stay here and the response for all questions or concerns are quickly answered.
Reviewed By: Stephen
“Great stay!
Review Date: 01/12/2021
Trip Date: 01/26/2021
"“Our stay was great, thank you so much!
Reviewed By: Amanda
Such a cool cottage!
Review Date: 11/11/2020
Trip Date: 11/03/2020
"The privacy in the back yard was amazing, the Rod and Reel pier is a block away and Bean Point is breathtaking!
Reviewed By: Frederick
The location was great!
Review Date: 10/13/2020
Trip Date: 10/07/2020
"“House was clean and everything was in working order. The location was great. Quiet street, but close enough to restaurants and businesses. Definitely stay here again.”
Reviewed By: Stephen
Ideal location and great pool area
Review Date: 09/12/2020
Trip Date: 08/08/2020
"We had an incredible time, and we loved the location! The pool was so great and perfect for cooling off. A very well equipped kitchen as well. The only issue we had was the pool light wasn’t working and there are only motion lights in the back so it was pretty dark after the sunsets but the property manager was very kind with addressing the issue. With everything going on they were unable to fix this during our stay but it was not a big deal we still had a wonderful time and would rent again! Thanks so much for a wonderful stay!
Reviewed By: Mackenzie K
Great Amenities!
Review Date: 09/01/2020
Trip Date: 08/15/2020
"“This house has all the amenities for a large family needs! Very spacious nice rooms! Nice kitchen with all pots and pans, dishes, and utensils. I was impressed by finding a French coffee press. If I knew I wouldn’t bring my own. For an avid cook like myself, I was very impressed with the selection. All bathrooms had towels and beach towels as well. The master shower was amazing and large enough for two people! The Master bedroom had a king bed and a TV in a room. The family room was full of interesting books, board games, and puzzles on the shelves. We love the backyard which was a highlight of our stay! It had a nice in-ground pool, gas grill, tables and chairs for a large family! The walk to the beach is not even 2 min. The peer is super close offering restaurants for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and a great view! I’ll be booking again next year! Thank you!”
Reviewed By: Anonymous
Home away from home
Review Date: 08/22/2020
Trip Date: 08/22/2020
"Very nice home for a big family like ours! This house offers great amenities, spacious rooms, beautiful backyard with a nice pool! We grilled almost every night and enjoyed pool activities with kids. The walk to the beach is not even a block away. Make sure to have breakfast or lunch at Rod and Peer. The beach nearby is very quiet and private. Personnel at Beach Rentals are very professional and super friendly! We look forward coming back next year!
Reviewed By: Yana J
